Mediaweek
Vinyl Media

Our Sites

Network Partners

Social media advertising is like eating soup with a fork

There is no doubt that social media gets results. But how many impressions, how much creative, and how much repetition does it take to produce those results?

By Lyndall SpoonerPublished Nov 17, 2026
5 min read
Lyndall Spooner, 5D V3

By Lyndall Spooner, Founder and CEO, 5D

Social media advertising is often described as the most efficient form of marketing ever invented. It can identify likely buyers, deliver personalised messages and connect exposure directly to conversion.

But what if we have mistaken measurability for efficiency?

There is no doubt that social media gets results. But how many impressions, how much creative, and how much repetition does it take to produce those results? Social media can resemble eating a bowl of soup with a fork. You will eventually finish the soup, but that does not make the fork an efficient tool.

The use of social media tends to cluster around particular moments: when we first wake up, during breaks in the day, and while we are unwinding at night. These are not necessarily the moments when we are thinking most carefully. We often reach for social media because we are tired, bored, distracted, or looking for effortless entertainment. We want something easy to process, not a complex argument requiring sustained attention.

Our mental state influences how marketing works. When we are depleted or distracted, we are more likely to rely on quick impressions, emotional cues, social proof, and familiar mental shortcuts. In the language of dual-process theory, social media frequently speaks to System 1, our fast, intuitive and automatic mode of thinking.

Speaking to System 1 makes social media highly effective at prompting immediate, low-risk behaviour. A snack, beauty product, inexpensive piece of clothing, or TV subscription trial can be discovered, socially validated, and purchased within minutes. The distance between stimulus and response is almost non-existent. For FMCG and other low-consideration categories, that can be extremely powerful.

mediaweek
Morning Report

The leading media trade publication in Australia.

Get our top stories straight to your inbox daily by signing up to our Newsletter

By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy. We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services.

Many traditional media encounters take place under different conditions. Television, print, cinema and outdoor advertising do not always reach people in their “cognitive prime”, but they are less closely tied to the frictionless purchase mechanisms of social media.

Their role is also often different. Traditional media can create familiarity, trust and meaning well before someone enters the market. That is particularly important in categories such as banking, insurance, cars and major household purchases. Those decisions are rarely completed impulsively. People investigate options, compare providers and consider the consequences of making the wrong choice.

System 2, our slower and more deliberate mode of thinking, plays a larger role here. The buyer may eventually approach the decision rationally, but the brands included in the consideration set are not generally selected from scratch. Brand equity has already shaped which organisations feel credible and safe.

The two thinking modes broadly reflect Les Binet and Peter Field’s distinction between long-term brand building and short-term activation. Brand building creates future preference while activation converts existing demand or desire into an immediate response.

Social media is exceptionally good at harvesting. The danger comes when marketers start mistaking harvesting for growing.

Traditional media planning was always conscious of waste. Marketers debated reach, frequency, and the point at which another exposure ceased to add value.

Social media has made waste less visible because every exposure produces data. An impression appears in a dashboard, enters an attribution model, and the precision of the number gets mistaken for the value of the exposure.

But consider the experience of someone seeing the same ad repeatedly. The algorithm has identified them as a likely customer, so it keeps serving the message. They may see it 10, 20 or even 50 times. Sometimes they have already bought the product. Sometimes they decided days ago that they were not interested.

When the same people receive the same message again and again, advertising stops expanding demand. Brands spend money talking to customers they have already persuaded or who have rejected the brand, while failing to reach the light buyers and future customers required for growth. That’s over concentration.

High frequency also creates a production problem. Creative wears out quickly when it is repeatedly presented on a personal screen. Brands respond by producing more versions, more edits, more formats, and more “content” to keep the feed fresh. That’s an efficiency problem.

The media placement may appear inexpensive, but the system consumes creative at extraordinary speed. The brand must continually feed the algorithm simply to maintain performance. Meanwhile, repeated exposure can turn recognition into irritation and distinctiveness into wallpaper.

Most attribution systems reward the channel standing closest to the transaction. Social media therefore receives credit for catching the customer at the end of the journey, even when TV, outdoor, word of mouth, or years of brand investment created the preference in the first place. The final touch is easy to measure, but that does not mean it did all the work.

Social media clearly works, but what kind of work it is doing, for which categories, and at what total cost.

Marketing efficiency should not be judged only by cost per click or immediate conversion. It should also consider:

  • How many exposures were required;
  • How many reached genuinely new customers;
  • How quickly the creative wore out;
  • Whether demand was created or merely captured;
  • Whether the activity strengthened or depleted the brand; and
  • How much of the result would have occurred anyway.

Social media may be an excellent activation channel, particularly where decisions are immediate, inexpensive and low risk. But treating it as the default answer for every marketing problem encourages brands to optimise the last step of the journey while neglecting everything that made the customer take that step.

The fork is moving. The dashboard is recording every movement. Eventually, some soup reaches the customer. But before declaring the process efficient, perhaps we should ask why we aren’t using a spoon.

More from Mediaweek

mediaweek
Morning Report

The leading media trade publication in Australia.

Get our top stories straight to your inbox daily by signing up to our Newsletter

By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy. We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services.